Propane Tank Sizes & Cost: 120, 250, 500 & 1,000 Gallon Guide (2026)
Published tank and install prices, fill costs, dimensions, and the rent-vs-buy sum for every residential propane tank size. Tank prices are seller list prices checked October 20, 2026; fill costs use the EIA weekly residential propane price.
Source: EIA propane data + published seller listings. Week ending 16 November 2026. Refreshed 19 November 2026.
Residential Propane Tank Sizes at a Glance
Purchase prices are tank-only list prices from Chimney Cricket (Florida, Arcosa tanks); installation prices are Tankfarm's complete above-ground packages (Connecticut, Massachusetts, Rhode Island and parts of New Hampshire, sold only to its propane customers, trenching extra), both checked October 20, 2026. They are two sellers on different terms, not a national range: Tankfarm's installed 1,000-gallon package is below Chimney Cricket's bare tank. Rental fees are Polk-Burnett's (Wisconsin) 2025-26 schedule, charged only when deliveries fall below half the tank's capacity; it lists none for 1,000 gallons. Dimensions are from Manchester Tank's above-ground spec sheet (rev. 4/11/2025) and the sellers' listings. Fill cost is the usable gallons times the EIA national average.
The 80% Fill Rule: Why Your Tank is Never Completely Full
Residential propane tanks are filled to only 80% of their rated capacity under NFPA 58. Liquid propane expands as it warms, and the remaining 20% vapor space, called the "outage," leaves room for that expansion. This is why your 500-gallon tank only receives about 400 gallons per fill, and why your delivery receipt will show 380 to 420 gallons for a nominally "full" 500-gallon tank.
The driver fills to the mark on the tank's fixed liquid level gauge (the outage valve, which vents a little vapor until liquid appears at 80%). Small portable cylinders from 4 to 40 lb must also carry an overfill prevention device (OPD). All the fill costs shown on this site are calculated using the 80% rule.
Rent vs Buy: The Breakeven Sum
| Factor | Rental | Ownership |
|---|---|---|
| Up-front cost | Set fee, if any (Polk-Burnett: $100) | Installed price (Tankfarm: $2,444 to $7,825 above ground, 120 to 1,000 gal) |
| Annual rental fee | Set by supplier (Polk-Burnett: $50 to $200 for 120 to 500 gal, waived at half-capacity deliveries) | $0 |
| Supplier flexibility | Locked to one supplier | Shop all suppliers |
| Per-gallon price | Your supplier's price | The best price you can get |
| Yearly saving from owning | Baseline | Rent + price gap x your gallons |
| Maintenance | Supplier handles it | Your responsibility |
| Breakeven | N/A | Installed price / yearly saving |
Worked Example (500-gallon tank, published prices)
- Installed price: from $5,587 (Tankfarm 500-gallon above-ground package)
- Rental fee: $200 a year (Polk-Burnett, charged only below half-capacity deliveries)
- Price gap: what your supplier charges a renter over the best price you could get as an owner
Above Ground vs Underground Propane Tanks
| Factor | Above Ground | Underground |
|---|---|---|
| Installed price (Tankfarm, 500 gal) | From $5,587 | $12,049 |
| Visual impact | Visible, can be screened with plantings | Invisible above ground |
| Inspection ease | Easy - visible daily | Requires special equipment |
| Temperature protection | Exposed to summer heat and winter cold | Protected by earth (stable temp) |
| Corrosion risk | Surface rust possible over time | Requires special coating; anode protection |
| HOA/zoning | Sometimes restricted | Often allowed where above-ground is not |
| Setback requirements | 10 ft from buildings (500 gal) | 10 ft from buildings |
Our recommendation: Choose above-ground unless you have specific HOA requirements, aesthetic priorities, or are in a climate with extreme temperature swings where underground stability provides meaningful benefits. In Tankfarm's published packages underground roughly doubles the installed price ($12,049 against from $5,587 for 500 gallons), which rarely makes sense for most homeowners. Prices checked October 20, 2026.